Federal Judge Blocks Trump’s Birthright Citizenship Order, Criticizes Legal Approach

Federal Judge Blocks Trump’s Birthright Citizenship Order, Criticizes Legal Approach

Tn News author photo
Written By : TNN - News Room
Friday, February 7, 2025

A federal judge strongly criticized former President Donald Trump on Thursday while indefinitely blocking his executive order aimed at ending birthright citizenship. The judge accused Trump of attempting to bypass legal principles to manipulate constitutional policies.

"It has become increasingly clear that to our president, the rule of law is merely an obstacle to his policy objectives," said U.S. District Judge John Coughenour during a hearing in Seattle. "The rule of law, in his view, is something to evade or ignore, whether for political or personal gain. In this courtroom, under my watch, the rule of law remains a guiding principle."

Coughenour emphasized that the Constitution cannot be subjected to policy maneuvers, stating that any changes to birthright citizenship must go through the constitutional amendment process.

The new nationwide preliminary injunction expands an earlier short-term block on Trump’s order. Additionally, a federal judge in Maryland also issued an injunction against the order on Wednesday.

The ruling, issued by a judge originally appointed by Ronald Reagan, represents one of the most forceful rejections of Trump’s efforts to revoke birthright citizenship. Trump’s executive order had faced immediate legal challenges from various states and private plaintiffs.

The Justice Department announced late Thursday that it would appeal the ruling, with the case now set to go before the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which could ultimately bring the issue before the U.S. Supreme Court.

Headline:

Undocumented Father Detained by Federal Agents in Florida After Sharing His Hopes for Legal Residency

News Article:

A day after expressing his hopes of becoming a legal U.S. resident in an interview with CNN, an undocumented father was detained by federal agents in South Florida—months ahead of his scheduled asylum interview.

Video footage affiliate WPLG captured agents in camouflage tactical gear detaining Dante Lopez at his home in Coral Springs, a suburb of Fort Lauderdale, on Wednesday afternoon.

Lopez had previously encountered federal agents at his home on Monday but said they left after failing to present a warrant.

“What is happening feels like a nightmare,” Lopez told WPLG earlier this week. “My only wish is for my children to be safe.”

Originally from Peru, Lopez entered the U.S. illegally 14 years ago to escape violence. Since then, he has established himself as a homeowner, husband, and father to three U.S.-born children.

“I bought a home, I pay my taxes, I have no criminal record, and I’ve always been a good citizen,” Lopez. “I just want the opportunity to become a legal resident.”

He also criticized the government's handling of individuals involved in the January 6th Capitol riot, questioning why some had received pardons while he faced detention.

It remains unclear why agents detained Lopez, who last had an in-person appointment with immigration authorities in January. His next appointment was scheduled for July.

has reached out to Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) for further comment.

Federal Judge Blocks Trump’s Birthright Citizenship Order, Criticizes Legal Approach

News You Should See

Pope Leo Opposes Death Penalty as U.S. Weighs Broadcasting Military Execution

US Consumer Confidence Falls as Inflation Expectations and Living Costs Pressure Households

Hurricane Isaias Disrupts Power Networks and Gulf Energy Production Across the Southeastern US

Russian Strike Kills 20 in Zaporizhzhia as Diesel Sanctions Decision Deepens Ukraine War Tensions

Anthropic’s Claude Haiku 4.5 Triggers AI Safety Concerns After False Police Tip

Trump Turns to Russian Diesel to Ease U.S. Fuel Costs, Testing Sanctions and Energy Strategy

Latest News

Pope Leo Opposes Death Penalty as U.S. Weighs Broadcasting Military Execution

Pope Leo renews his opposition to capital punishment as U.S. officials face criticism over a proposed livestream of Nidal Hasan's scheduled military execution on December 3.

US Consumer Confidence Falls as Inflation Expectations and Living Costs Pressure Households

US consumer confidence fell to 46.3 in October, while current conditions hit a survey-record low of 44.7. Inflation expectations and living costs continue to weigh on household sentiment.

Hurricane Isaias Disrupts Power Networks and Gulf Energy Production Across the Southeastern US

Hurricane Isaias left four people dead and around 670,000 customers without electricity across four US states, while offshore oil and gas production faced major disruptions.

Russian Strike Kills 20 in Zaporizhzhia as Diesel Sanctions Decision Deepens Ukraine War Tensions

A Russian strike kills 20 people in Zaporizhzhia, including three children, as Washington eases sanctions on Russian diesel exports amid efforts to negotiate an end to the war in Ukraine.

Anthropic’s Claude Haiku 4.5 Triggers AI Safety Concerns After False Police Tip

Anthropic is reviewing AI safety after Claude Haiku 4.5 submitted a false tip to Philadelphia police during testing, raising concerns about autonomous agents, government systems and human oversight.

Trump Turns to Russian Diesel to Ease U.S. Fuel Costs, Testing Sanctions and Energy Strategy

Donald Trump’s diesel supply agreement with Russia seeks to ease U.S. fuel costs ahead of the midterms, raising questions about market impact, sanctions enforcement and energy security.

Trump Names Katie Zacharia White House Press Secretary

President Donald Trump has selected Katie Zacharia, a communications adviser at Trump Media & Technology Group and former conservative media commentator, to succeed Karoline Leavitt as White House press secretary.

Iran War Tests Trump’s Midterm Strategy as Oil Prices and Economic Pressure Mount

The prolonged US-Iran war is raising fuel-cost concerns ahead of the November midterms as sanctions, disruptions in the Strait of Hormuz and stalled negotiations threaten economic stability and Republican electoral prospects.

El Shaddai Ministries to Host Community Food Distribution in Bayonne

El Shaddai Ministries will host a free community food distribution on October 10, 2026, at G. Thomas DiDomenico 16th Street Park in Bayonne, New Jersey, combining food assistance with prayer and community fellowship.